Forums118
Topics9,224
Posts196,102
Members1,325
|
Most Online5,850 Feb 29th, 2020
|
|
S |
M |
T |
W |
T |
F |
S |
|
|
|
|
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
6
|
7
|
8
|
9
|
10
|
11
|
12
|
13
|
14
|
15
|
16
|
17
|
18
|
19
|
20
|
21
|
22
|
23
|
24
|
25
|
26
|
27
|
28
|
29
|
30
|
|
Here is a link to show exactly where the Space Station is over earth right now: Click Here
|
|
5 registered members (dedication, Karen Y, 3 invisible),
2,537
guests, and 8
spiders. |
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: kland]
#158576
11/20/13 07:29 PM
11/20/13 07:29 PM
|
SDA Charter Member Active Member 2019
20000+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 22,256
Southwest USA
|
|
M: I asked APL this question and am interested in your answer. It seems as though he believes Jesus commanded Moses to kill criminals (capital punishment) and combatants (wage war) because Moses mistakenly believed killing is in accordance with God's will. However, it is possible APL believes this insight misrepresents his view. I am waiting for him to clarify his view. I have no idea what you believe.
K: Hmmm. Maybe I don't agree if APL said this. Could you show me where he said that? Why do you disagree with it? More importantly, what do you believe? "Create = cause to exist. Empower = cause to act." then: God created gravity. In what way, after creating gravity, did He have to "cause it to act"? Gravity is not self-acting. Nothing in nature can act in and of it self. Everything is dependent upon Jesus to empower it to act. This insight is clearly articulated in the following passage: God is constantly employed in upholding and using as His servants the things that He has made. He works through the laws of nature, using them as His instruments. They are not self-acting. Nature in her work testifies of the intelligent presence and active agency of a Being who moves in all things according to His will. {MH 416.1}
It is not by inherent power that year by year the earth yields its bounties and continues its march around the sun. The hand of the Infinite One is perpetually at work guiding this planet. It is God's power continually exercised that keeps the earth in position in its rotation. It is God who causes the sun to rise in the heavens. He opens the windows of heaven and gives rain. {MH 416.2}
It is by His power that vegetation is caused to flourish, that every leaf appears, every flower blooms, every fruit develops. MH 416.3}
The mechanism of the human body cannot be fully understood; it presents mysteries that baffle the most intelligent. It is not as the result of a mechanism, which, once set in motion, continues its work, that the pulse beats and breath follows breath. In God we live and move and have our being. The beating heart, the throbbing pulse, every nerve and muscle in the living organism, is kept in order and activity by the power of an ever-present God. {MH 417.1} Jesus created the heart to beat and pump blood throughout the body. However, Jesus must also empower it to act. The heart cannot act in and of itself. Jesus set nothing in motion to act independent of His power and guidance. The same is true of everything in nature - including gravity.
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: kland]
#158578
11/20/13 07:39 PM
11/20/13 07:39 PM
|
SDA Charter Member Active Member 2019
20000+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 22,256
Southwest USA
|
|
M: I'm sorry I haven't been more clear on this question. Hopefully I can answer your question in no uncertain terms. Yes, I believe there are times when circumstances force Jesus to cause disease, death, and destruction. Plenty of passages have been posted in support of this insight. However, there are times when circumstances force Jesus to command holy angels to cause disease, death, and destruction. Passages have also been posted in the support of this insight. And there are times when circumstances force Jesus to permit evil angels to cause disease, death, and destruction. The passage you posted above is one of many in support of this insight.
K: So would you say Ellen White is wrong and that she should have said: Sickness, suffering, and death are [also] work of an antagonistic power [besides God and His angels]. Satan is the destroyer [sometimes, but God other times]; God is the restorer [except when He is destroying]. No need to insert such things in her writings. Just as you don't expect it in the passages that support the other two insights named above. For example: The depths of the earth are the Lord's arsenal, whence were drawn weapons to be employed in the destruction of the old world. Waters gushing from the earth united with the waters from heaven to accomplish the work of desolation. Since the Flood, fire as well as water has been God's agent to destroy very wicked cities. These judgments are sent that those who lightly regard God's law and trample upon His authority may be led to tremble before His power and to confess His just sovereignty. As men have beheld burning mountains pouring forth fire and flames and torrents of melted ore, drying up rivers, overwhelming populous cities, and everywhere spreading ruin and desolation, the stoutest heart has been filled with terror and infidels and blasphemers have been constrained to acknowledge the infinite power of God. {PP 109.1} Do you see a need to insert brackets in the passage above to reflect your view (the withdraw and permit principle of punishment)?
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: kland]
#158579
11/20/13 07:52 PM
11/20/13 07:52 PM
|
SDA Charter Member Active Member 2019
20000+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 22,256
Southwest USA
|
|
M: Hopefully I can answer your question in no uncertain terms.
K: Which really means, given a situation, such as tornadoes, you really don't know whether evil or good caused the destruction? The sentence you extracted above was tied to a specific point and wasn't intended to be used indiscriminately. However, to address your point, just as you can't know with certainty whether Jesus 1) withdrew His restraining hand and permitted nature to wreak havoc, or 2) withdrew His protection and permitted evil angels to wreak havoc, so too, I cannot say with certainty which way and means Jesus used to accomplish His plan and purpose. Do you believe Jesus permits and regulates (ensures they do not exceed His permissive will) natural disasters? Or, do you believe they happen in and of themselves and that the outcome is the result of natural law (once Jesus set them in motion the laws of nature act according to predictable principles)?
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: Mountain Man]
#158597
11/21/13 09:55 PM
11/21/13 09:55 PM
|
SDA Active Member 2024
5500+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 6,499
Midland
|
|
M: I asked APL this question and am interested in your answer. It seems as though he believes Jesus commanded Moses to kill criminals (capital punishment) and combatants (wage war) because Moses mistakenly believed killing is in accordance with God's will. However, it is possible APL believes this insight misrepresents his view. I am waiting for him to clarify his view. I have no idea what you believe.
K: Hmmm. Maybe I don't agree if APL said this. Could you show me where he said that? Why do you disagree with it? More importantly, what do you believe? I asked you to substantiate your claim. You seemed to have evaded it. What should I conclude? Gravity is not self-acting.
Ummm.... Ummmm.... I don't think I'll bother. I think there's some underlying communications issues here.
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: Mountain Man]
#158598
11/21/13 10:00 PM
11/21/13 10:00 PM
|
SDA Active Member 2024
5500+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 6,499
Midland
|
|
No need to insert such things in her writings. Just as you don't expect it in the passages that support the other two insights named above. For example: The depths of the earth are the Lord's arsenal, whence were drawn weapons to be employed in the destruction of the old world.
Do you see a need to insert brackets in the passage above to reflect your view (the withdraw and permit principle of punishment)? I'm only inserting so I can understand your view since your view does not support the statement. Or are you saying no need to insert things, because you already have when you read it? But you are ignoring the whole point of discussion of which APL has brought up numerous times. What does it mean: arsenal, weapons, kill? But then, you have demonstrated so well, that when the Bible says God slew Saul, yet elsewhere we find Saul slew himself, you mean it to mean that God caused Saul to kill himself.
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: Mountain Man]
#158600
11/21/13 10:21 PM
11/21/13 10:21 PM
|
SDA Active Member 2024
5500+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 6,499
Midland
|
|
M: Hopefully I can answer your question in no uncertain terms.
K: Which really means, given a situation, such as tornadoes, you really don't know whether evil or good caused the destruction? The sentence you extracted above was tied to a specific point and wasn't intended to be used indiscriminately. Very well: M: Yes, Jesus causes disease, death, and destruction. K: So how do you deal with this? "Sickness, suffering, and death are work of an antagonistic power. Satan is the destroyer; God is the restorer. {MH 113.1} I don't believe you had said. But have you changed your mind or do you still say, "Yes, Jesus causes disease, death, and destruction." M: I'm sorry I haven't been more clear on this question. Hopefully I can answer your question in no uncertain terms. Yes, I believe there are times when circumstances force Jesus to cause disease, death, and destruction. Plenty of passages have been posted in support of this insight. However, there are times when circumstances force Jesus to command holy angels to cause disease, death, and destruction. Passages have also been posted in the support of this insight. And there are times when circumstances force Jesus to permit evil angels to cause disease, death, and destruction. The passage you posted above is one of many in support of this insight. In what way was I using it indiscriminately? Which really means, given a situation, such as tornadoes, you really don't know whether evil or good caused the destruction? You are saying that if satan personates Christ, you would have no way of knowing from the actions he does as to whether it is good or evil. I believe you would say, if have not said, that actions of themselves are not good nor evil, but only determined if we know who does them and why. Your ideas remind me of eastern type of beliefs of ying/yang type of stuff where there is no satan, only God and He creates both good and evil. Why? So that we can appreciate the good all the more. Only problem of this comparison with you is that you say there is no good or evil, only good and evil motives. Satan and God can do the exact same actions, in fact, that God causes/uses/entices/whatever satan to do things and then you call them "good". Satan will work with all his deceptive power to influence the heart and becloud the understanding, to make evil appear good, and good evil. {AA 431.1}
Who can know, in the moment of temptation, the terrible consequences which will result from one wrong, hasty step! Our only safety is to be shielded by the grace of God every moment, and not put out our own spiritual eyesight so that we will call evil, good, and good, evil. Without hesitation or argument we must close and guard the avenues of the soul against evil. {AH 403.1}
"Everyone that doeth evil is good in the sight of the Lord, and He delighteth in them; or, Where is the God of judgment?" Malachi 2:17. Saith the word of God: "Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness." Isaiah 5:20. {DD 21.1}
And probably most important: Terrible had become the darkness of the nation that had rejected the light of truth. “The grace that bringeth salvation” had appeared; but France, after beholding its power and holiness, after thousands had been drawn by its divine beauty, after cities and hamlets had been illuminated by its radiance, had turned away, choosing darkness rather than light. They had put from them the heavenly gift, when it was offered them. They had called evil good, and good evil, till they had fallen victims to their willful self-deception. Now, though they might actually believe that they were doing God service in persecuting his people, yet their sincerity did not render them guiltless. The light that would have saved them from deception, from staining their souls with blood-guiltiness, they had willfully rejected. {GC88 229.1}
Rather frightening to say the least. ..
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: kland]
#158619
11/22/13 08:20 AM
11/22/13 08:20 AM
|
Banned SDA Active Member 2015
3500+ Member
|
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 3,613
USA
|
|
Kland, God told Samuel to tell Saul to destroy the Amalekites. But the Lord sent His servant with another message to Saul. By obedience he might still prove his fidelity to God and his worthiness to walk before Israel. Samuel came to the king and delivered the word of the Lord. That the monarch might realize the importance of heeding the command, Samuel expressly declared that he spoke by divine direction, by the same authority that had called Saul to the throne. The prophet said, “Thus saith the Lord of hosts, I remember that which Amalek did to Israel, how he laid wait for him in the way, when he came up from Egypt. Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass.” The Amalekites had been the first to make war upon Israel in the wilderness; and for this sin, together with their defiance of God and their debasing idolatry, the Lord, through Moses, had pronounced sentence upon them. By divine direction the history of their cruelty toward Israel had been recorded, with the command, “Thou shalt blot out the remembrance of Amalek from under heaven; thou shalt not forget it.” Deuteronomy 25:19. For four hundred years the execution of this sentence had been deferred; but the Amalekites had not turned from their sins. The Lord knew that this wicked people would, if it were possible, blot out His people and His worship from the earth. Now the time had come for the sentence, so long delayed, to be executed. {PP 627.3} The forbearance that God has exercised toward the wicked, emboldens men in transgression; but their punishment will be none the less certain and terrible for being long delayed. “The Lord shall rise up as in Mount Perazim, He shall be wroth as in the valley of Gibeon, that He may do His work, His strange work; and bring to pass His act, His strange act.” Isaiah 28:21. To our merciful God the act of punishment is a strange act. “As I live, saith the Lord God, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked; but that the wicked turn from his way and live.” Ezekiel 33:11. The Lord is “merciful and gracious, long-suffering, and abundant in goodness and truth, ... forgiving iniquity and transgression and sin.” Yet He will “by no means clear the guilty.” Exodus 34:6, 7. While He does not delight in vengeance, He will execute judgment upon the transgressors of His law. He is forced to do this, to preserve the inhabitants of the earth from utter depravity and ruin. In order to save some He must cut off those who have become hardened in sin. “The Lord is slow to anger, and great in power, and will not at all acquit the wicked.” Nahum 1:3. By terrible things in righteousness He will vindicate the authority of His downtrodden law. And the very fact of His reluctance to execute justice testifies to the enormity of the sins that call forth His judgments and to the severity of the retribution awaiting the transgressor. {PP 628.1}
Why do you deny that God commanded Moses and Saul to destroy the Amalekites?
Search me oh God and know my heart, test me and know my anxious thoughts, see if there is any offensive way in me and lead me to the way everlasting. Amen
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: kland]
#158626
11/22/13 04:26 PM
11/22/13 04:26 PM
|
SDA Charter Member Active Member 2019
20000+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 22,256
Southwest USA
|
|
K: I asked you to substantiate your claim. You seemed to have evaded it. What should I conclude? Please reread my post and note the disclaimer. However, I would like to know what you believe. Why do you think Jesus commanded Moses to kill? M: Gravity is not self-acting.
K: Ummm.... Ummmm.... I don't think I'll bother. I think there's some underlying communications issues here. The statement is in harmony with the passage posted above. Nothing falls to the ground without Jesus empowering the laws of nature to act. Jesus did not set gravity in motion so that it works in and of itself without His involvement. The reason things fall to the ground is because Jesus empowers gravity to act. Do you think gravity acts in and of itself without Jesus' involvement, without Jesus empowering it? Do you think Jesus set it in motion like a perpetual motion machine so that it acts without Him?
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: kland]
#158627
11/22/13 08:37 PM
11/22/13 08:37 PM
|
SDA Charter Member Active Member 2019
20000+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 22,256
Southwest USA
|
|
M: Do you see a need to insert brackets in the passage above to reflect your view (the withdraw and permit principle of punishment)? K: I'm only inserting so I can understand your view since your view does not support the statement. Or are you saying no need to insert things, because you already have when you read it? But you are ignoring the whole point of discussion of which APL has brought up numerous times. What does it mean: arsenal, weapons, kill? But then, you have demonstrated so well, that when the Bible says God slew Saul, yet elsewhere we find Saul slew himself, you mean it to mean that God caused Saul to kill himself. Again, there is no need to insert brackets. Each passage says what it means and means what it says. The passage you posted clearly supports the withdraw and permit principle of punishment. And the passages I posted clearly support the other principles of punishment, namely, either Jesus does it Himself or He commands holy angels to do it. The death of King Saul is an example of Jesus using His enemies to punish sinners. As I pointed out, King Saul most likely would not have killed himself if Jesus had blessed him in battle.
|
|
|
Re: Does God Punish? (Part 2)
[Re: kland]
#158629
11/22/13 08:53 PM
11/22/13 08:53 PM
|
SDA Charter Member Active Member 2019
20000+ Member
|
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 22,256
Southwest USA
|
|
M: I'm sorry I haven't been more clear on this question. Hopefully I can answer your question in no uncertain terms. Yes, I believe there are times when circumstances force Jesus to cause disease, death, and destruction. Plenty of passages have been posted in support of this insight. However, there are times when circumstances force Jesus to command holy angels to cause disease, death, and destruction. Passages have also been posted in the support of this insight. And there are times when circumstances force Jesus to permit evil angels to cause disease, death, and destruction. The passage you posted above is one of many in support of this insight.
K: You are saying that if satan personates Christ, you would have no way of knowing from the actions he does as to whether it is good or evil. I believe you would say, if have not said, that actions of themselves are not good nor evil, but only determined if we know who does them and why. Your ideas remind me of eastern type of beliefs of ying/yang type of stuff where there is no satan, only God and He creates both good and evil. Why? So that we can appreciate the good all the more. Only problem of this comparison with you is that you say there is no good or evil, only good and evil motives. Satan and God can do the exact same actions, in fact, that God causes/uses/entices/whatever satan to do things and then you call them "good". Jesus commanded Moses to execute capital punishment and to wage war. It was good. Fire blazed out from God in the most holy place and burned alive Nadab and Abihu. It was good. PS - None of the passages you posted above explain why Jesus commanded Moses to kill criminals and combatants.
|
|
|
|
Here is the link to this week's Sabbath School Lesson Study and Discussion Material: Click Here
|
|
|